Columbia Benton Springs Fleece
Top PickWhat We Like
- Warm for its weight on cool mornings
- Shaped, flattering cut that layers under a shell
- Deep pockets and a substantial full-length zip
- Lowest price tier of any jacket here
Worth Noting
- Not windproof or water-resistant
- Type
- Fleece
- Closure
- Full zip
- Department
- Women's
Fleece is the least glamorous thing in this guide and the one we reach for most. The Benton Springs is brushed thick on both sides, warmer than its weight suggests, and it sits at the bottom of the price range here — which is why it takes the top spot ahead of the technical shells that follow.
Where it beats other fleeces is the shape. It's cut in at the waist rather than dropping straight, so it reads as a jacket and not a zip-front sweatshirt, and it layers under a rain shell without bunching at the shoulders. The sleeves run long, which the elastic cuffs solve, and the body runs generous on most frames — but the fit isn't consistent enough to order blind, so try it on before you cut the tags.
The small things are done well: pockets deep enough for a phone and keys, a zip with enough substance that it doesn't ripple, and contrast trim at the pocket and zip pull on some colorways that makes a basic fleece look chosen rather than default. Colors are the one gamble, since a few read darker on screen than in daylight and the black is a softer black than a true one.
Nothing about it is technical, and that's the point: it's the layer for a cool morning, a cold office, a car that never quite warms up. Ours has been in a tote, over a dress, and under a shell on a wet afternoon, and it has never been the thing we regretted packing.
Bottom line: Warm for its weight, flattering over a sweater, and the least expensive way to look put together on a cool morning — this is the fall jacket we recommend first.