Orolay Thickened Down Jacket
Top PickWhat We Like
- Warmest jacket in this group
- Side zippers widen the coat as needed
- Plenty of zippered pockets
- Fleece-lined hood
Worth Noting
- Zippers can catch and stick
- Hood is attached and cannot be removed
- Hood
- Attached, fleece lined
- Pockets
- Multiple, zippered
- Side Zippers
- Yes, for extra room
- Stated Weight
- 2.73 lb
Worn back to back with everything else on this list, this is the coat that settled the warmth question. The fill sits thick across the chest and shoulders, the hood is fleece lined and stays put in wind, and it is the one we reach for when the forecast is bad enough that the rest of the group feels like a gamble.
The details are what make it liveable rather than merely warm. The side zippers open the coat up so it stops fighting you when you sit down or add a sweater underneath, and the pockets are zippered and plentiful — though the hand pockets sit higher than on most coats, so you will find yourself glancing down to find them.
Sizing is the part to get right. This one runs small and the sleeves are cut close, so go up a size, especially if you plan to wear a sweater under it. It rewards buying the bigger of your two sizes rather than the one you usually take.
What surprised us is how little it looks like gear. The shape holds up over layers instead of turning into a marshmallow, and it is neat enough to wear to work without feeling like you dressed for a hike. That is most of why it stays by the door rather than in the closet.
Bottom line: We recommend it to anyone whose winter regularly drops below freezing: it is the warmest coat in this group, and the pockets and side zippers make it easy to live in.