Columbia Benton Springs Full Zip
Top PickWhat We Like
- Warm without bulk in fall and mild winter
- Flattering cut that skims the body
- Deep front pockets and elasticized cuffs
- Wide color range with contrast trim on some
Worth Noting
- Sizing runs generous; sleeves long on petite frames
- Colors don't always match the photos
- Style
- Full-zip fleece jacket
- Fleece
- Smooth, lightweight
- Pockets
- Two front hand pockets
The Osito is softer and the Fast Trek II layers better, but the Benton Springs is the one we recommend first. The weight is what does it: warm enough for a cold morning, thin enough that you don't overheat at a desk or in a car with the heat on. And the cut skims the body instead of squaring it off, which is why it reads as a jacket rather than a zip-up sweatshirt.
The details are plain but well judged. The front pockets are deeper than they look, the cuffs are elasticized so a pushed-up sleeve stays on your forearm instead of sliding back down, and some colorways finish the zip and pocket edge in a contrast shade. It packs small, too — this is the one that ends up folded in a tote or behind a car seat and still looks presentable when you pull it out.
What it isn't is a winter coat. On a hard cold snap you want a shell over it, and it goes under one without bunching at the shoulders, more easily than the thick pile jackets here. That's the trade for a fleece you can also wear at a desk in November, and for three seasons out of four it's the right one.
Bottom line: Our pick for almost everyone: warm for fall and mild winter, light enough to keep on indoors, and cut to flatter rather than bundle. Start here unless you need a hood.