Thayers Unscented Witch Hazel
Top PickWhat We Like
- Alcohol-free, so it doesn't leave skin tight
- Witch hazel and aloe refresh without stripping
- Lifts the last of cleanser and makeup
- Gentle enough for twice-daily use
Worth Noting
- Large bottle is awkward in a travel kit
- Size
- 12 fl oz
- Alcohol
- Alcohol-free
- Formula
- Witch hazel and aloe
- Fragrance
- Unscented
A cotton pad of this after a balm cleanser comes away faintly tinted, and that's the plainest argument for keeping a toner in the routine at all: it picks up what the cleanser left. It's also the bottle we hand to more people than any other here, because it's the hardest of the eight to get wrong — no acids, no added fragrance in this version, and no drying alcohol to leave skin tight.
The formula is witch hazel and aloe, and the aloe is what separates it from the astringent your mother kept under the sink. Skin feels clean and comfortable rather than stripped, it's gentle enough for morning and night, and it doubles as a body swipe, an after-shave splash and a hot-day refresh. For one inexpensive bottle, that's a lot of jobs.
Where it stops short is depth. Witch hazel is a mild astringent, so genuinely dry or barrier-damaged skin won't get back the lipids a ceramide toner puts in — which is exactly why CeraVe sits right below this one. On normal, oily or combination skin, the balance is right.
Two small things worth knowing. Use a pad if you want the wipe-and-check effect, or press it in with your palms to avoid tugging at your skin. And keep the big bottle in the cabinet with a little decanted into a spray bottle for the counter — twelve ounces is more than you want to be lifting twice a day.
Bottom line: If you want one toner that suits most skin, costs little, and won't sting, start here — we hand this bottle to more people than any other.