NYX Butter Gloss
Top PickWhat We Like
- Sheer-to-medium color that builds in a second coat
- Creamy, buttery feel with no stickiness
- Lowest price band in this group
Worth Noting
- Fades after eating or drinking
- Shade
- Summer Fruit (hot pink)
- Finish
- Glossy
- Texture
- Buttery, non-sticky
- Coverage
- Sheer to medium
Summer Fruit is the shade that changed our minds about hot pink. In the tube it looks loud; on lips it lands as a sheer, juicy flush that brightens a bare face with nothing else on it, and the texture is the cushiony, buttery kind that gives Butter Gloss its name. Of everything we tested, this is the best overall summer color: visible pigment, real shine, and no tackiness ten minutes in.
Coverage sits between sheer and medium, so one swipe reads as a tint and a second builds toward the pink in the tube. That range is what we want in July — a full-coverage lip feels like too much at noon, a bare lip feels unfinished — and the same tube carries into the evening. The finish is glossy rather than wet-looking, which holds up better in bright daylight than a high-shine lacquer.
The shade range is wide enough to go bright or nearly bare in the same formula, and it sits in the lowest price band here, which matters for something you will reapply several times a day. One thing to know before you judge a shade: the color reads more saturated in the tube than on lips, so give the second coat a chance before deciding it is too much.
Bottom line: We recommend starting here: real color, a creamy non-sticky finish, and a price that makes reapplying all afternoon painless.