Neutrogena Makeup Remover Wipes
Top PickWhat We Like
- Lifts waterproof mascara in one pass
- Fragrance-free and ophthalmologist tested
- Sturdy plant-based cloth, compostable at home
- Twin pack keeps cost per wipe low
Worth Noting
- Can sting reactive skin around the eyes
- Cloth
- 100% plant-based, compostable
- Formula
- Fragrance-free micellar
- Removal
- Up to 99% of makeup
- Pack Size
- 2 packs of 25
The number on the pack is 99% of makeup, waterproof mascara included, and one wipe gets you there. A full face of foundation, blush, and long-wear mascara comes off in a single pass, without the second cloth you'd expect around the lash line. That's why this is our default pick: not because it does anything exotic, but because it finishes the whole job quickly and doesn't leave skin tight afterwards.
The formula is the quiet part. It's fragrance-free, with a triple emollient blend and none of the alcohol, sulfates, or dyes that make a wipe sting, and it's ophthalmologist- and dermatologist-tested — worth knowing when you're dragging a cloth across the thinnest skin on your face. The cloth itself is 100% plant-based and compostable at home, and it holds together through a full face instead of pilling into lint on your cheek.
Two 25-count packs are the other reason it wins: one for the bathroom, one for a bag, and a cost per wipe at the low end of this group. Press the seal flat each time you open it, because a pack left loose gives up its moisture by the last few wipes. And if your skin flares at everything, start with Cetaphil or Aveeno Calm + Restore instead.
Bottom line: Our default pick: it lifts waterproof mascara in one pass, the formula is fragrance-free, and the twin pack keeps the cost per wipe low — buy it unless your skin is easily stung.