Revlon ColorStay Full Cover Foundation
Top PickWhat We Like
- Full coverage without a heavy, mask-like feel
- Matte finish flattens shine along scar edges
- Transfer-proof wear that resists heat
- Tube format makes thin-layer application easy
Worth Noting
- Fifteen shades thin out at the deeper end
- Wear
- Up to 24 hours; transfer-proof
- Finish
- Matte
- Shades
- 15
- Coverage
- Full
A pitted scar is a shadow before it is a discoloration. Anything with a sheen catches light along the rim of the dent and makes it read deeper, which is why we put a matte, full-coverage foundation at the top of this list rather than the prettiest glowy one. Revlon's ColorStay Full Cover flattens that shine and covers in the same pass, and it does it without the heavy, mask-like feel we braced for.
The texture is the surprise. It comes out of the tube as a light whipped mousse, and a pea-sized amount covers a cheek. We press it in with a damp sponge rather than sweeping, because a brush stroke drags product straight back out of an indentation. Two thin layers do more for texture than one thick one, which is the mistake that turns full coverage cakey.
The listing promises up to 24 hours and heat-and-sweat resistance. What we can tell you is that it stayed where we put it through a long day without migrating into the scars, and that it sets to a finish that barely needs powder. Powder is where most texture coverage goes wrong: too much and every edge of the dent shows.
Fifteen shades is the catch, workable through the light and medium range and thin at the deeper end, where a shade that is slightly off is far more visible over texture than over smooth skin. For a whole face of coverage, though, nothing else here comes as close on finish and wear together.
Bottom line: Full, matte coverage that stops indented texture catching the light, in a formula light enough to press into thin layers — our first choice for scarring across a whole cheek.