NYDJ Marilyn Straight Jeans
Top PickWhat We Like
- Higher waistband stays put when you bend
- Stretch holds its shape through a workday
- Dressy enough for the office
Worth Noting
- Long inseam, and no petite sizing
- Cut
- Straight leg
- Style
- Marilyn
- Made For
- Women's
Most straight-leg jeans ask you to choose: fit the hip and fight the waist, or fit the waist and give up on the hip. The Marilyn takes the decision away with a higher waistband and stretch through the denim, so the back of the waist stays covered when you bend, sit, and get up again. Of everything here, it's the pair that needs the least adjusting through a normal day.
What settled it for us is the fit itself. The waist and seat hold up better than any other pair in this set, and that matters more than the wash or the hardware. The stretch recovers, too: plenty of soft jeans feel good at eight in the morning and bag out by two, while these keep their line through a workday. That's the difference between a jean you wear to the office and one you save for Saturdays.
Ordering takes a little nerve, because these run large. The waist is where the extra fabric shows first, so if you're between sizes, take the smaller one, and don't assume the size you wear in another label carries over. Try them on with the shoes you'll actually pair them with before the tags come off.
The denim itself is smooth and stretchy with a faint sheen, closer to a polished trouser than to rigid selvedge. We like that for a pair that has to work at dinner, and it's why these read dressier than a five-pocket jean has any right to. If you want heft and a dry hand, they aren't the pair for you; for everyone else, this is where to start.
Bottom line: The straight leg we recommend first: the higher waist stays put when you bend and the stretch holds its shape all day, provided you order a size down.